Comments on: Disclosure http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/ neat fun stuff Wed, 08 Feb 2012 21:30:01 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Matt Cuttshttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-454149 Matt Cutts Sun, 17 Jan 2010 00:38:27 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-454149 Hey everybody, given this this is a disclosure page rather than a "proper blog post," I'm going to go ahead and close comments on this page. Hey everybody, given this this is a disclosure page rather than a “proper blog post,” I’m going to go ahead and close comments on this page.

]]>
By: Richardhttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-451963 Richard Tue, 12 Jan 2010 08:21:09 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-451963 I think its overdue that the web is cleaned up by the regulators. Plenty of abuse by others that gives us honorable & honest online merchants a bad name. Can I put my <a href="http://RichardBaldock.com/contact-us" rel="nofollow">name</a> on the list for the stuff you give away. : )Cool site. I think its overdue that the web is cleaned up by the regulators. Plenty of abuse by others that gives us honorable & honest online merchants a bad name.
Can I put my name on the list for the stuff you give away. : )

Cool site.

]]>
By: Joe C.http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-443059 Joe C. Wed, 23 Dec 2009 19:52:00 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-443059 Matt,Thanks for posting so frequently lately. I hope you enjoy our feedback to your posts. I'd like to think that is what keeps you engaged :-). I Hope you have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! Matt,

Thanks for posting so frequently lately. I hope you enjoy our feedback to your posts. I’d like to think that is what keeps you engaged :-) . I Hope you have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!

]]>
By: Jonathanhttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-439897 Jonathan Thu, 17 Dec 2009 16:17:50 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-439897 Don't give in to the state's demands.Failing to disclose that you've received financial compensation for endorsing a product is not an unjust act. You're not selling the product, and therefore it is up to the readers to decide whether or not to believe you. It'd be nice if you chose to disclose it, and I'd obviously prefer it -- but no one, especially not the state, has the right to force you to disclose it.It's kind of like if you get a random phone call from someone who says that he knows who will win tomorrows football game. It's up to you as to whether or not to believe him. If you choose to believe him, and bet some money and lose... well, that's on you. Sure, the guy was a jerk, an idiot... but you chose to believe him.If a company misrepresents a product in order to get a sale, then *this* is an unjust act, and therefore you are entitled to financial restitution from the company.Interesting, too, that when you pay the fine, the state gets the money, isn't it? Don’t give in to the state’s demands.

Failing to disclose that you’ve received financial compensation for endorsing a product is not an unjust act. You’re not selling the product, and therefore it is up to the readers to decide whether or not to believe you. It’d be nice if you chose to disclose it, and I’d obviously prefer it — but no one, especially not the state, has the right to force you to disclose it.

It’s kind of like if you get a random phone call from someone who says that he knows who will win tomorrows football game. It’s up to you as to whether or not to believe him. If you choose to believe him, and bet some money and lose… well, that’s on you. Sure, the guy was a jerk, an idiot… but you chose to believe him.

If a company misrepresents a product in order to get a sale, then *this* is an unjust act, and therefore you are entitled to financial restitution from the company.

Interesting, too, that when you pay the fine, the state gets the money, isn’t it?

]]>
By: Dani Gorgonhttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-434489 Dani Gorgon Tue, 08 Dec 2009 10:49:33 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-434489 Great disclosure cut from Matt Cutts! Great disclosure cut from Matt Cutts!

]]>
By: Kelvin Servigonhttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-434466 Kelvin Servigon Tue, 08 Dec 2009 10:02:22 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-434466 Looks like you're so generous. :) Looks like you’re so generous. :)

]]>
By: Lee Willishttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-431582 Lee Willis Thu, 03 Dec 2009 17:57:21 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-431582 Matt,I think your policy misses the point somewhat. What you've written is great, but I don't think it actually covers the issue (for your blog), which is, as I see it:Does Matt Cutts write about products because he wants to, or because he's asked to (Whether indirectly because of his employment by Google or by A.N.Other company who may well ask you to write about their product even if they don't give you anything of value).For Google products, while your policy makes it clear that you receive income from Google, but it's not clear whether that relationship has any bearing on what you post about, or the opinions posted on your blog. (I think since you've declared your salary/stock from Google we can all take a guess at the answer - but this is about clarity right?)For non-Google products while you've clarified you don't receive any benefit for writing about them - it's still not clear that if you wrote about product X it would be without influence (Maybe the CEO of the company is one of your high-school friends for example)I think a simple statement such as:"This blog represents the personal opinion of Matt Cutts and I always give my honest opinions, findings, beliefs, or experiences on topics or products."or an alternative, if the above isn't 100% true (and by the way, for anyone who has a blog that is even vaguely related or includes posts about their employer I'd expect this to be the case)I should note that, as others have said, I respect your professional, and personal integrity greatly, and I'm pretty confident that I know where you stand, but I do think the policy as-is doesn't cover this important point. Matt,

I think your policy misses the point somewhat. What you’ve written is great, but I don’t think it actually covers the issue (for your blog), which is, as I see it:

Does Matt Cutts write about products because he wants to, or because he’s asked to (Whether indirectly because of his employment by Google or by A.N.Other company who may well ask you to write about their product even if they don’t give you anything of value).

For Google products, while your policy makes it clear that you receive income from Google, but it’s not clear whether that relationship has any bearing on what you post about, or the opinions posted on your blog. (I think since you’ve declared your salary/stock from Google we can all take a guess at the answer – but this is about clarity right?)

For non-Google products while you’ve clarified you don’t receive any benefit for writing about them – it’s still not clear that if you wrote about product X it would be without influence (Maybe the CEO of the company is one of your high-school friends for example)

I think a simple statement such as:

“This blog represents the personal opinion of Matt Cutts and I always give my honest opinions, findings, beliefs, or experiences on topics or products.”

or an alternative, if the above isn’t 100% true (and by the way, for anyone who has a blog that is even vaguely related or includes posts about their employer I’d expect this to be the case)

I should note that, as others have said, I respect your professional, and personal integrity greatly, and I’m pretty confident that I know where you stand, but I do think the policy as-is doesn’t cover this important point.

]]>
By: Shivahttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-426637 Shiva Wed, 25 Nov 2009 22:30:49 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-426637 Can you please help me to find out whether the below site is fraud or not? Well, this is the story: I read online about the Next generation TLD's and thought it would be best to get .xyz domain (similar to .COM, .NET..) It was late evening and found a website http://www.nextgentlds.com and I got a mail from cs@mabuhayhosting.com - that they are about to register that top TLD - and they belong to the Approved and Accredited by the Internet Names Authorization & Information Center (INAIC) - http://inaic.org Just minutes (just minutes) after paying online I felt so stupid that there was no contact numbers from them and called Chase - they mentioned they took care of it - finally to find today that the money $1026.78 is gone. I am filing for a dispute and sent mail to both Mabuhay, and the money was taken by ZYZTM Research Division Europe #10 B.V. through RBS World pay. Do you have any idea on these guys? Have you heard about these scam? I have Norton anti-virus installed - so when searching google - it always mention which sites are harmful - though I am at fault in this incident - I wish Google could do something to track these guys and warn or better yet just not to index them. I am following some legal actions and filing complaints to International crime websites. Hope something happens. Can you please help me to find out whether the below site is fraud or not?

Well, this is the story:

I read online about the Next generation TLD’s and thought it would be best to get .xyz domain (similar to .COM, .NET..)

It was late evening and found a website http://www.nextgentlds.com and I got a mail from cs@mabuhayhosting.com – that they are about to register that top TLD – and they belong to the Approved and Accredited by the Internet Names Authorization & Information Center (INAIC) – http://inaic.org

Just minutes (just minutes) after paying online I felt so stupid that there was no contact numbers from them and called Chase – they mentioned they took care of it – finally to find today that the money $1026.78 is gone. I am filing for a dispute and sent mail to both Mabuhay, and the money was taken by ZYZTM Research Division Europe #10 B.V. through RBS World pay.

Do you have any idea on these guys? Have you heard about these scam? I have Norton anti-virus installed – so when searching google – it always mention which sites are harmful – though I am at fault in this incident – I wish Google could do something to track these guys and warn or better yet just not to index them.

I am following some legal actions and filing complaints to International crime websites. Hope something happens.

]]>
By: Adamhttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-415145 Adam Sat, 07 Nov 2009 03:27:55 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-415145 It is very refreshing to see that ethics are alive and well in America. I am a Sydney based web designer and I refuse to join the resellers program of my favourite hosting company for the simple reason that I don't believe that I could strongly recommend the host if I took a cut for doing it. I applaud you for your strong moral standing. Great to see Matt - and thanks for the cool tips that I have picked up from your site recently. ---> (sorry about the spelling, I am Australian and we spell a little differently). It is very refreshing to see that ethics are alive and well in America. I am a Sydney based web designer and I refuse to join the resellers program of my favourite hosting company for the simple reason that I don’t believe that I could strongly recommend the host if I took a cut for doing it. I applaud you for your strong moral standing. Great to see Matt – and thanks for the cool tips that I have picked up from your site recently. —> (sorry about the spelling, I am Australian and we spell a little differently).

]]>
By: Steve Andersonhttp://www.mattcutts.com/blog/disclosure/#comment-411094 Steve Anderson Fri, 30 Oct 2009 13:46:11 +0000 http://www.mattcutts.com/blog/?p=3173#comment-411094 Hey Matt,Seems you give stuff away that companies give you...if apple sends you a macbook remember me ;). Hey Matt,

Seems you give stuff away that companies give you…if apple sends you a macbook remember me ;) .

]]>